Psychologist vs Psychotherapist. Understanding the Distinction Between Psychologists and Psychotherapists: Therapeutic Approaches and Costs Explained

Click Me

As a Psychotherapist, I frequently encounter inquiries about providing mental health care plans, only to disappointingly respond with a negative. This common misconception often arises from the blurred lines between the roles of psychologists and psychotherapists. In this blog post, I aim to clarify the differences between these professions, shed light on their respective therapeutic approaches, and unravel the costs associated with seeking their services.

Psychologist vs. Psychotherapist: Understanding the Roles

Psychologists:

Psychologists are professionals who have obtained a degree in psychology. They are trained in the assessment, diagnosis, and treatment of mental health disorders using a variety of therapeutic techniques. Psychologists often specialize in different areas such as clinical, counseling, or educational psychology. They can administer psychological tests, conduct research, and provide counseling and psychotherapy.

Psychotherapists: On the other hand, psychotherapists come from diverse educational backgrounds, including psychology, social work, counseling, or psychiatry. They offer talk therapy or psychotherapy to individuals, couples, families, or groups to address various emotional, behavioral, and mental health issues. Psychotherapists may hold master's degrees, licenses, or certifications in specific therapeutic modalities, such as somatic psychotherapy, process orientated psychotherapy, cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT), psychodynamic therapy, or interpersonal therapy.

Therapeutic Approaches: Tailoring Treatment to Individual Needs

Both psychologists and psychotherapists employ a range of therapeutic approaches to address the unique needs of their clients:

Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy (CBT): Focuses on identifying and changing negative thought patterns and behaviors to promote positive coping strategies and emotional well-being.

Psychodynamic Therapy: Explores unconscious processes and unresolved conflicts from the past to gain insight into current emotional difficulties and foster personal growth.

Humanistic Therapy: Emphasizes self-exploration, personal responsibility, and growth in a supportive and non-judgmental therapeutic environment.

Family Systems Therapy: Examines family dynamics and interactions to address relational issues and improve communication and conflict resolution skills.

The choice of therapeutic approach often depends on the client's presenting concerns, preferences, and treatment goals. Psychologists may incorporate a broader range of assessment tools and evidence-based interventions into their practice, while psychotherapists may focus on talk therapy techniques, somatic techniques or have a more wholistic transpersonal approach to therapy.

Cost Considerations: Navigating Mental Health Care Expenses

Navigating the costs associated with mental health care can be daunting. While both psychologists and psychotherapists offer valuable services, there are differences in terms of coverage and out-of-pocket expenses:

Mental Health Care Plans: In many countries, including Australia, mental health care plans are available through general practitioners (GPs) or psychiatrists. These plans typically cover a limited number of sessions with psychologists, who are registered providers under the national healthcare system. Unfortunately, psychotherapists may not be eligible to provide services under these plans, resulting in a difference in out-of-pocket expenses for clients seeking their care.

Fee Structure: Psychotherapists often operate on a fee-for-service basis, charging clients directly for each session. Rates may vary depending on the therapist's qualifications, experience, and location. Psychologists working in private practice also charge fees for their services, but clients with mental health care plans may be eligible for subsidized sessions.

A mental health care plan gives you access to 6 rebated sessions with a psychologist.

Unfortunately you can’t claim 100% of the cost back.

As of 2024 you are able to claim back a rebate of $137.05 for a Clinical Psychologist or $93.35 for a Registered Psychologist for a 50+ minute session provided you have a Mental Health Care Plan.

The APS National Schedule of Recommended Fees 2023-2024 has the standard 46 to 60-minute psychology consultation fee at $300. This is a recommendation only.

Understanding the distinction between psychologists and psychotherapists is crucial for making informed decisions about mental health care. While both professions offer valuable support and therapeutic interventions, differences in training, therapeutic approaches, and cost structures may influence the choice of provider. Whether seeking treatment from a psychologist or a psychotherapist, prioritizing your mental health and well-being is paramount. Remember to explore your options, ask questions, and advocate for the care that best meets your needs and preferences.

Natasha Lumsden is a Psychologist and part of the Tribe 180 community. With the Medicare rebate your out of pocket expense would be $106.65 and full fee $200.

Natasha is taking booking for online clients.